Background: According to the World Health Organization, probiotics are live microorganisms that, when administered in adequate amounts, confer a health benefit to the host. The use of oral probiotics in children to improve oral health may lead to nonpathogenic bacteria replacing cariogenic bacteria. The Evora Plus oral probiotics tablet is the first such oral probiotics tablet containing a proprietary blend of three select species of naturally occurring oral bacteria, each with a specific function for maintaining a healthy oral environment. These strains include Streptococcus oralis KJ3sm, Streptococcus uberis KJ2sm, and Streptococcus rattus JH145. Aim: To compare the levels of salivary total bacterial count, salivary pH levels, and salivary S. mutans count before and after consumption of the Evora Plus oral probiotic tablet. Materials and methods: Around 40 caries-free schoolchildren from Daksh International School, Gadarwara, Madhya Pradesh, India, aged 12–14 years, were selected and divided equally into two groups—group A, in which total salivary bacterial count and pH were evaluated, and group B, in which salivary S. mutans count and pH were evaluated. These groups were further subdivided into group A1 and group B1, which served as the control groups not receiving the Evora Plus oral probiotic tablet, and group A2 and group B2, which were the test groups consuming the Evora Plus oral probiotic tablet for 30 days. Assessment of salivary samples for total bacterial count was done at baseline and after 30 days for groups A1 and B1. Salivary pH estimation was done at baseline and after 30 days for the entire group, and salivary S. mutans count was done at baseline and after 30 days for groups A2 and B2. Salivary pH level was checked using a digital pH meter; nutrient agar was used for salivary total bacterial count, while Mitis salivarius bacitracin agar was used for salivary S. mutans count. The number of colonies was counted and subjected to statistical analysis using unpaired and paired Student's t-test. Results: The study showed a significant reduction in salivary total bacterial count and salivary S. mutans counts, as well as a significant increase in salivary pH after 30 days in the Evora Plus oral probiotic group compared with the group not receiving the Evora Plus oral probiotic tablet. Conclusion: Cariogenic microorganisms could be reduced by an oral probiotic formulation. Thus, the use of the Evora Plus oral probiotic tablet could be recommended for the prevention of enamel demineralization.